Book Reviews
British Moths and Butterflies
- A Photographic Guide by Chris Manley.
Published by A & C Black Publishers Ltd., 2008. £25. 352 pp, colour photos,
softback ISBN 978-0-7136-8636-4 (available online at www.acblack.com)
As interest in moth recording has increased in recent times so has the available
literature, and currently there are two popular books for the identification of the
larger moths: The Colour Identification Guide to Moths of the British Isles by
Bernard Skinner and the Field Guide to the Moths of Great Britain and Ireland by
Paul Waring and Martin Townsend. Chris Manley’s book is a recent candidate for
joining this group with its comprehensive species coverage of the butterflies, larger
moths and a sizeable number of the micro-moths. The book’s introduction gives its
objectives as providing enough information to identify almost any of the larger
moths or butterflies and secondly to be visually stimulating, to celebrate and raise
awareness of the beauty and diversity of butterflies and moths.
There are several short sections at the beginning and the end of the book giving
information on how best to see and photograph lepidoptera, their lifecycles, how
they are classified and a table of larval foodplants. Although the coverage of these
subjects is rather brief it is what I would expect from an identification guide, a more
expansive approach to these subjects would detract from the primary focus of
species identification and is already covered in more detail in other moth books.
Most of the book is taken up with colour photographs and species accounts of the
moths and butterflies. Coverage of the larger moths and butterflies is quite
comprehensive with images of over 850 species of larger moth and 74 species of
butterfly included. In addition nearly 500 of the 1500+ species of micro-lepidoptera
in the country are also illustrated. A smaller section has 314 photographs of the nonadult
stages. I would estimate that three-quarters of the page space is taken up with
colour photographs, something of an achievement given the price of the book. The
remaining page space contains short textual accounts for each species with
information on its size, flight period, rarity, habitats, food-plants and brief help on
identification where appropriate. For some species there are several photographs
showing variations, aberrations and identification features. It would be better if more
photographs showing identification features were included and illustrations of
features on the underside or hindwing are largely lacking in those cases where they
would be useful.
As a guide for use in the field the book has a couple of negative points: it lacks a
hardback cover and the relatively flimsy paper used may not last as long as in the
field as other moth guides. As a guide for identifying micro-lepidoptera I would
hesitate to recommend it due to its patchy species coverage and lack of detailed
information on differentiation of confusion species. However, it is refreshing to see
so many photographs of micro-lepidoptera illustrated in a book aimed at the more
general moth recorder; it may entice a few more recorders to begin studying these
families in greater depth.
Does the book meet its objectives? As an identification guide it would probably
not be my first choice, I think the Skinner and Waring books provide more help to
the recorder in this area. The textual accounts in these two books give more
information on identification features and the more uniform layouts of moth images
makes comparison between species easier. This new book would certainly make a
good additional identification resource, providing further images for comparison
during the identification process. As a book that aims to celebrate the beauty and
variety of moths I think it would be very difficult to find a better example with the
number and variety of high quality colour photographs within its covers.
Tony Prichard
The Mammals of Suffolk by Simone Bullion. Suffolk Wildlife Trust and Suffolk
Naturalists Society, 2009: 207pp. Hardback: £20.00
November 19, 2011 9:14"10" align="left" />Mammals tend to have been a neglected group of wildlife except
by land managers, farmers and game keepers all of whom have
sought to control perceived ‘pest’ species. Hence, there has
been recording of the ‘bags’ made on estates and even in church
records where pests such as bats sometimes had a price on their
heads. The demise of species such as the pine marten was not
formally recorded but estate records show how the number
killed each year diminished but the date of extinction, probably
sometime in the mid nineteenth century, remains unknown. (By
definition, a rare species is difficult to find!)
Amongst the naturalists, mammals received scant attention because many are
nocturnal and hide away by day and often, it only has been possible to discover
much about species’ life histories with the use of modern technology. Generally,
most mammalogists get to know about the presence of animals by what they leave
behind them - droppings, scats or in modern parlance - poo!
Gathering together the scattered notes and records was first attempted by the
Victorians such as Thomas Bell, 1874, in his account of The History of British
Quadrupeds and J G Millais epic tomes on The Mammals of Great Britain and
Ireland. These volumes provide largely anecdotes of discoveries and observations
made by all kinds of people who often did not understand what they observed but,
with present knowledge, we can interpret those carefully recorded notes.
Further assemblages of the then current knowledge were made by Barrett-
Hamilton with Hinton in their multi-part ‘A history of British Mammals’ published
from 1910 - 1921. Also, The Victoria History of the Counties of England (1911) for
the first time includes sections specifically on the mammals of individual counties,
including Suffolk. However, although interesting snippets of information was given
on most of the Suffolk mammals, usually relating to named sites with dates, there
was little knowledge of the distribution, population sizes or habits of each species of
a kind we now enjoy.
The next milestone in the Suffolk mammalian story was Claud Ticehurst’s paper
on Suffolk Mammals published in the Transactions of the Suffolk Naturalists’
Society in 1932. However, this was really an annotated list with the particular
interest being a description of the extinct species especially from the fossil record
such as from the red crag strata. To me, one of the interesting comments concerned
the otter which he described as ‘I think there is hardly a suitable stream ... in the
County which lacks otters’. We now know that species became extinct around 45
years later but with the immensely successful river clean up and re-introductions,
now has become a common Suffolk species again. No attempt had been made to
produce distribution maps for species as there were no data bases. The next
progression in assembling knowledge about our mammals came from our former
SNS member, Dr Harrison Matthews with his British Mammals (Collins: New
Naturalist 1952). This detailed the biology and natural history of each species as
well as descriptions of distributions and comments on abundance. Later the
Mammal Society of the British Isles produced the Handbook of British Mammals
with first edition in 1964 with 465 pages to 4th edition in 2008 with 799 pages. That
last volume was a full compendium of present knowledge about all species and is a
standard work where mammal enthusiasts would find both a digest of the latest
information as well as a comprehensive source work bibliography.
So it is with that background that the new book by Dr Bullion was eagerly
awaited. The amount of effort required to produce such a work cannot be
overstated. When taking on such a project it soon becomes a daunting prospect of
how to find and collate all the sources of information and to write a reference and
readable book while fulfilling a busy job helping to protect habitats and species in
Suffolk. However, the task has been achieved with an attractive and concise volume
which will form a standard work and stimulus for more work in our County.
The volume starts with an incredible list of all the sources of records, about 560
individuals submitting information, most in the last 15 years or so. The book then
has sections on the history of mammals and a systematic treatment of all the known
extant species and concludes with an interesting chapter on surveying for mammals
and what can be done to encourage various species and what we can do to help
reverse declines. Of course, this latter depends on detailed research to establish
exactly what individual species require and recipes on what we can do in talking
with landowners to help them manage habitats in an effective way.
A nice touch is a brief introduction to each mammal group with the history of
introductions for such species as rabbits and un-natural introductions such as bats
arriving as stowaways on ships or military aircraft.
Each species account gives information on the history, distribution and aspects of
their behaviour and natural history. Distribution maps are augmented with a box
giving vital information on the species and drawings showing food or other signs
which can identify who produce the signs and all accounts are lavishly illustrated
with colour photographs of the animals and habitats.
So, with Simone Bullion’s book we have an most attractive work to grace every
bookshelf of all those interested in wildlife in Suffolk (and adjacent counties) but the
real value is not for it to stay on the shelf but to be a stimulus for everyone to become enthused in
observing this diverse group of fascinating animals. Most of us
will have some of these species living in or visiting our gardens and there is always
the opportunity to make new observations on aspects of their lifestyles.
As a teenager born in Bury St Edmunds and educated in Suffolk I was introduced
in 1952 to a research project begun by SNS members in 1947 and on joining the
Mammal Society in 1957 the fourth Earl of Cranbrook (the President of that Society,
as well as SNS at the time) wrote to me saying he was ‘ploughing a lonely
mammalian furrow in Suffolk’ and thereby persuaded me to join our Society. I
greatly valued the support he gave me in my career in mammal research and in
conserving mammals through the Wild Creatures and Wild Plants Act 1975 and the
Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981. He was a principal mover of these vital pieces
of legislation protecting Britain’s wildlife including some mammals.
Robert Stebbings
President, Suffolk Naturalists’ Society
To order a copy visit our publications page